sUse of this site means you accept its terms and conditions.
STATEMENTS SUPPORTING THE FORMAL NAMING OF SHARSMITH PEAK   

Back to Home page
Back to References and Resources

For statements of support, click here. Additional statements appear on the companion earlier website www.name4carl.org: exits.

Other current statements


From: martinrosen@earthlink.net [mailto:martinrosen@earthlink.net]
Sent: Friday, March 01, 2013 8:34 PM
To: email@sharsmithpeak.org
Subject: name the peak

Please add us to the list to committed supporters of this effort:

Martin Rosen, President Emeritus, Trust for Public Land

Joan Rosen, Volunteer Ranger Naturalist, Anza Borrego Desert State Park 

thank you,

marty rosen

The Rosens reside in Carmel, California. They are in California's 17th Congressional District and their U.S. Representative is Sam Farr, whom they say knew Ansel Adams well and may also have known Carl Sharsmith.


From: Jim Sano
Subject: RE: Sharsmith Peak proposal
To:Laurie...
Cc: billj@summitco.us, lenmckenzie@yahoo.com, "'Dick Ewart'" <dick_ewart@yahoo.com>
Date: Tuesday, February 26, 2013, 1:39 AM

Hi Laurie,

Bill asked that I respond to your email.

First, it is good to hear from you!  I am amazed how this initiative is bringing together so many of our former Yosemite colleagues and friends.

You may recall the notion of naming the highest peak south of White Mountain after Carl first surfaced in the late 1970's when I was nominally Carl's "supervisor."  During my NPS tenure  (1975-1986) the Tuolumne naturalists offered an all-day naturalist led hike every day. Two of the hikes were in the area of peak 12002 - the Skelton Lakes basin and the mines north of upper Gaylor Lake.  Dick Ewart and I informally talked a number of times about naming 12002 after Carl.  Why?  It is a peak easily viewed from the meadows, especially Puppy Dome.  And, it overlooks Carl's most beloved botanical area - the Dana Plateau (the location where he discovered the plant that is named after him.)  I fondly remember escorting Carl with Dick on his last hike up to the Dana Plateau to see the plant that is now named after him.  I will try to unearth the priceless photograph of Carl beaming when he reached the plateau.

If my memory serves me correctly Dick Ewart may have accompanied you on the attempts to take Carl to 12002. I know Dick and I talked with Carl multiple times about naming 12002 after him, as did others.  One of the individuals that comes to mind was a former Tuolumne visitor center interpreter Wilma Bowman ~ who took it upon herself to feed Carl a proper dinner throughout the summers.  I cannot recall Carl ever objecting to the suggestion.   

I know of no data on whether naming a mountain increases the number of visitors.  I would venture to say that most peak baggers do not otherwise assign much "significance" to peak 12002.  But that's just a hunch on my part.  Conness is the major draw for hikers/climbers along this section of the crest.  Those who go out of their way to go off trail to climb White Mountain likely do so without giving much thought to its name.  The same is probably true for Gibbs as well.  Also, the vast majority of hikers and climbers are largely ignorant of the history and significance of Yosemite's place names - many of which in the Tuolumne region are named after US army officers, their wives, and assorted geologists (e.g., I believe Conness never visited the Tuolumne area.)  The priority seems to be how high the mountain is...if the peak is in the top 3 or 5 in terms of height in the park...and lastly the shape of the peak. 

At the end of the day I think we all agree that we want a lasting tribute to Carl and his unmatched contributions to interpreting Yosemite's high country ~ before those who have first-hand knowledge of Carl fade into the sunset.

All the best,
Jim


James Sano| Vice President Travel, Tourism, and Conservation
World Wildlife Fund
1250 24th St. NW Washington DC 20037

From: Dick Ewart [mailto:dick_ewart@yahoo.com]
Sent: Monday, March 04, 2013 9:45 PM
To: Jim Sano
Cc: Laurie...

Subject: RE: Sharsmith Peak proposal

 Hi Jim and Laurie,
Thanks for forwarding me your letters.
I remember that Carl was pretty excited about having peak 12002 named in his honor.
I don't remember that other peaks were being considered, but that was entirely possible.
He always responded with his humble enthusiasm  when I talked about "his peak".
And I remember when Laurie, Margaret and I were camping up on his peak with him, that he was in absolute heaven being close to his beloved alpine flowers in that wet meadow. I also remember his excitement in anticipating a return to his peak one last time, and he was saddened by the thought that he might not make it. Whenever I talk about Carl to visitors today, which is quite often, I tell about the trip we made up to his peak before he died, and what great final pleasure that gave him.
If the peak does get named after Carl, will there be more people going to the top. There might be an insignificant increase. But the people that remember Carl are all getting old, so they will probably travel to the peak in their imagination instead.
Carl was expecting Peak 12002 to be named in his honor, and I would hate to disappoint him.

Dick

Send emails to Sharsmith Peak Committtee

Back to Home page
Back to References and Resources